Startled

/ˈstɑː.təld/

feeling or showing sudden shock or alarm.

"her startled eyes met his"

 /dɪˈsmeɪ/

cause (someone) to feel concern and distress. 'they were dismayed by the U-turn in policy' 

Dismayed
 /dɪˈsmeɪ/ cause (someone) to feel concern and distress. 'they were...

Amazed
/əˈmeɪzd/ greatly surprised; astonished.  "I was amazed that he could...

Confused
/kənˈfjuːzd/ (of a person) unable to think clearly; bewildered. "she was...

Excited
/ɪkˈsʌɪtɪd,ɛkˈsʌɪtɪd/ very enthusiastic and eager. "they...

Surprised
/səˈprʌɪz/ an unexpected or astonishing event, fact, etc. "the...

Emotions Wheel
I have enjoyed working with the emotions I found in Plutchik, but there are so many more...